Nursing Home Fines and Payment Denials Explained

A fine against a nursing home is called a civil money penalty. A payment denial means that Medicare or Medicaid stops paying for newly admitted residents. Both are federal enforcement remedies. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) or the state imposes them when an inspection finds that a home is not in substantial compliance with the requirements for taking part in Medicare and Medicaid. The rules are in 42 CFR part 488, subpart F, and CMS publishes each fine and payment denial of the last three years in its Penalties file.

The two penalties at a glance

Civil money penalty (fine)Denial of payment for new admissions
What it isAn amount of money per day of noncompliance, per instance, or bothNo Medicare or Medicaid payment for residents admitted on or after the effective date
Rule42 CFR 488.430 to 488.44442 CFR 488.417
Optional or requiredCMS or the state may impose itOptional in general. Required after 3 months without substantial compliance, or after substandard quality of care on the last three consecutive standard surveys
How it endsA per-day penalty runs until the facility achieves substantial compliance or is terminatedPayments resume when the facility achieves substantial compliance
In the CMS Penalties fileListed as "Fine", with the amount in whole dollarsListed as "Payment Denial", with a start date and a length in days

The legal basis

Under 42 CFR 488.400, sections 1819(h) and 1919(h) of the Social Security Act specify the remedies that the Secretary of Health and Human Services or the state may use when a skilled nursing facility (a Medicare nursing facility) or a nursing facility (a Medicaid nursing facility) is not in substantial compliance. The regulation states the purpose: to ensure prompt compliance with program requirements. Two definitions in 42 CFR 488.301 decide much of what follows.

The findings come from surveys, the inspections carried out by the state survey agency or by CMS. The inspections guide explains how deficiencies are cited and graded.

Who imposes a penalty

42 CFR 488.430 names two authorities: CMS or the state may impose a civil money penalty. CMS sends the written notice of a penalty to every facility except a nursing facility that is not operated by the state when the state itself is imposing the penalty. For payment denials, 42 CFR 488.417 says that CMS may deny payment to a Medicare facility, and that the state may deny payment to a Medicaid facility. With one exception for state-imposed fines on Medicaid-only facilities, remedies are imposed before any hearing is held.

How the amount of a fine is set

42 CFR 488.438 gives three ranges, each adjusted annually under 45 CFR part 102. The second column shows the figures printed in the regulation. The third shows the adjusted amounts in the table at 45 CFR 102.3 as in force on November 21, 2026, which carries the adjustment for 2025.

Type of penaltyRange printed in 42 CFR 488.438Adjusted range (2025)
Per day, deficiencies constituting immediate jeopardy$3,050 to $10,000$8,351 to $27,378
Per day, no immediate jeopardy, but actual harm or the potential for more than minimal harm$50 to $3,000$136 to $8,211
Per instance of noncompliance$1,000 to $10,000$2,739 to $27,378

The 2025 amounts were published in the Federal Register on January 28, 2026 (91 FR 3665) and took effect on publication. They apply to penalties assessed on or after that date for violations that occurred on or after November 2, 2015. The multiplier for 2025 was 1.02598, based on the change in the Consumer Price Index.

Within a range, the regulation lists the factors that CMS or the state must take into account:

A per-day penalty may start accruing as early as the date the facility was first out of compliance. If immediate jeopardy is removed but the noncompliance continues, the daily amount shifts to the lower range. For a repeated deficiency that earlier drew a lower penalty, the daily amount must be increased.

Two reductions written into the rule

35 percent for waiving a hearing. Under 42 CFR 488.436, a facility that waives its right to a hearing has the penalty reduced by 35 percent. A facility is considered to have waived that right 60 days after the date of the notice if CMS has received no request for a hearing. A fine of $10,000 would become $6,500.

50 percent for self-reporting and prompt correction. CMS reduces a penalty by 50 percent when the facility reported the noncompliance before CMS or the state identified it and corrected it within the time limits in 42 CFR 488.438. The reduction is not available when the noncompliance was a pattern of harm, widespread harm or immediate jeopardy, or resulted in the death of a resident. The facility must also waive its hearing. The regulation states that a facility never receives both reductions.

From notice to collection

  1. A survey finds that the facility is not in substantial compliance.
  2. CMS, or the state, sends a written notice of the penalty.
  3. For a penalty imposed by CMS that will be placed in escrow, 42 CFR 488.431 provides an opportunity for independent informal dispute resolution within 30 days of the notice of the penalty. An involved resident or resident representative and the state long-term care ombudsman are notified and may comment in writing.
  4. CMS may collect the penalty and place it in an escrow account on the date the dispute resolution is completed or 90 days after the notice, whichever comes first.
  5. The facility may request a hearing on the finding of noncompliance. It may appeal the finding that led to the remedy, but not the choice of remedy. A judge who finds that a basis for the penalty exists may not reduce it to zero.
  6. If the findings are reversed in a final decision, the amount owed to the facility is returned with interest. Otherwise the funds are distributed as described below.

Denial of payment for new admissions

A new admission is a resident admitted on or after the effective date of the denial. Residents admitted before that date who take temporary leave are not new admissions. CMS or the state may impose the remedy whenever a facility is not in substantial compliance. It becomes mandatory in two cases: the facility is still out of substantial compliance 3 months after the last day of the survey, or the state survey agency has cited substandard quality of care on the last three consecutive standard surveys. No payment is made for new admissions for the period between the date the remedy is imposed and the date the facility achieves substantial compliance.

Other remedies in the same rule

42 CFR 488.406 lists further remedies that CMS or the state can use alone or together with a fine:

Where the money goes

Under 42 CFR 488.433, ten percent of the penalty funds that CMS holds in escrow and that remain after a final decision is deposited with the Department of the Treasury. The remaining ninety percent must be used entirely for activities that protect or improve the quality of care or quality of life for residents. The funds may not pay for survey and certification operations. Penalties collected from Medicaid facilities are returned to the state, and those from facilities in both programs are divided in proportion to the Medicare and Medicaid beds in use.

CMS runs this through its Civil Money Penalty Reinvestment Program. It says the funds may be reinvested in activities that benefit nursing home residents, such as support for residents when a facility closes. The application process is managed by each state agency, and CMS publishes lists of funded projects and state fund balances.

What the Penalties data file contains

The CMS data dictionary describes the Penalties file as a list of the fines and payment denials received by nursing homes in the last three years. Each row has a penalty date, which is the date of the inspection that triggered the penalty, and a penalty type. A fine has an amount in whole dollars. A payment denial has a start date and a length in days. In the file with the processing date October 1, 2026 there are 15,007 rows: 12,638 fines and 2,369 payment denials, with penalty dates from October 17, 2023 to September 23, 2026. Across all homes, including those with none, the national average was 0.9 fines and $30,351 in fines per home.

A row in the file records an enforcement action tied to one inspection date. The file has no column for the status of a hearing or appeal. Each home's page on this site lists its fines and payment denials with dates and amounts as CMS reports them. See also the list of homes with fines. This site adds no assessment of its own.

Who to contact about a specific home

Remedies rest on noncompliance found during surveys. CMS says that state survey agencies investigate complaints about the quality of care a patient received in a health care facility, and it publishes contact information for each state survey agency. The complaint guide describes the official routes.

Sources

Every fact in this article was read at the official sources below. Read November 21, 2026.

  1. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations: 42 CFR part 488, subpart F: Enforcement of Compliance for Long-Term Care Facilities with Deficiencies (sections 488.400 to 488.456)
  2. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations: 42 CFR 488.301, Definitions
  3. Electronic Code of Federal Regulations: 45 CFR 102.3, Penalty adjustment and table
  4. Federal Register: Annual Civil Monetary Penalties Inflation Adjustment, final rule, 91 FR 3665 (January 28, 2026)
  5. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services: Civil Money Penalty Reinvestment Program
  6. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services: Nursing Home Data Dictionary, updated October 2026
  7. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Provider Data Catalog: Penalties (processing date October 1, 2026)
  8. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Provider Data Catalog: State US Averages (processing date October 1, 2026)
  9. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services: Contact Information for State Survey Agencies

Frequently asked questions

What is a civil money penalty against a nursing home?

It is a fine. Under 42 CFR 488.430, CMS or the state may impose a civil money penalty for the number of days a facility is not in substantial compliance with federal participation requirements, for each instance of noncompliance, or both. CMS describes these penalties as monetary penalties it may impose on nursing homes for each day or instance of noncompliance with Medicare and Medicaid requirements.

How much can a nursing home be fined?

The regulation sets ranges that the Department of Health and Human Services adjusts for inflation each year. The table at 45 CFR 102.3 in force on November 21, 2026 carries the 2025 adjustment: $136 to $8,211 per day when there is no immediate jeopardy, $8,351 to $27,378 per day for immediate jeopardy, and $2,739 to $27,378 per instance.

What does denial of payment for new admissions mean?

Medicare or Medicaid does not pay the facility for residents admitted on or after the date the remedy takes effect. Under 42 CFR 488.417 it is required when a facility is still not in substantial compliance 3 months after the last day of the survey, or when it has been cited with substandard quality of care on its last three consecutive standard surveys. Residents admitted before that date are not new admissions.

Can a nursing home get a fine reduced?

Yes, in two ways set by regulation. If the facility waives its right to a hearing, the penalty is reduced by 35 percent under 42 CFR 488.436. If the facility reported the problem itself and corrected it promptly, and the other conditions of 42 CFR 488.438 are met, CMS reduces the penalty by 50 percent. A facility cannot receive both reductions.

Where does the money from nursing home fines go?

Under 42 CFR 488.433, ten percent of the funds collected and held in escrow by CMS goes to the Department of the Treasury. The remaining ninety percent must be used for activities that protect or improve the quality of care or quality of life for residents. CMS says a portion of the penalties is returned to the states where they were imposed, through its Civil Money Penalty Reinvestment Program.

How far back do the published fines go?

The CMS data dictionary describes the Penalties file as a list of the fines and payment denials received by nursing homes in the last three years. In the file with the processing date October 1, 2026, the penalty dates run from October 17, 2023 to September 23, 2026.