Otterbein Seniorlife: nursing homes, ratings and inspections

CMS groups 20 nursing homes in 2 states under the chain name Otterbein Seniorlife, with 1,344 certified beds. CMS's definition of a chain: “Unique name identifying a group of nursing homes that share at least one individual or organizational owner, officer, or entity with operational/managerial control”. The name is the one CMS gives the group; the homes may be owned and run by separate companies.

Data: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), Provider Data Catalog. Data as of , released by CMS on October 28, 2026. Data and method

20nursing homes
1,344certified beds
2states
$168,595in fines, last three years (9 fines)

CMS overall ratings of the 20 homes

5 of 5 stars3 (15.0%)
4 of 5 stars7 (35.0%)
3 of 5 stars6 (30.0%)
2 of 5 stars2 (10.0%)
1 of 5 stars2 (10.0%)

The group in the CMS files

Chain averages as CMS publishes them in the Provider Information file, next to CMS's national averages.
CMS figure (1 to 5 stars)Otterbein SeniorlifeUS average
Chain average overall rating3.43.0
Chain average health inspection rating2.92.8
Chain average staffing rating3.33.0
Chain average quality measure rating4.43.7
Means and counts of the homes' CMS figures, computed by this site from the Provider Information file. They describe the homes listed here and are not a rating of the operator.
FigureOtterbein SeniorlifeAll US homes
Total nurse staffing hours per resident day (mean of homes reporting)4.113.90
Total nursing staff turnover, % (mean of homes reporting)47.945.3
Homes with a fine in the last three years6 (30%)6,468 (44%)
Homes with the CMS abuse icon0 (0%)1,401 (10%)
Special Focus Facilities / candidates0 / 087 / 440
Ownership type of the homes
0 for profit, 19 non-profit, 1 government
Homes certified for Medicaid
19 of 20
Homes that changed ownership in the last 12 months
0
Homes with a denial of payment for new admissions, last three years
0

Homes by state

The homes

Homes CMS lists under Otterbein Seniorlife, by state and name.
Nursing homeOverall ratingHealth insp.StaffingQualityCertified bedsLast standard inspectionHealth deficienciesFines
Otterbein Franklin Seniorlife Comm Res & Com Care Franklin, IN333208Aug 21, 202551 · $14,186
Avalon by Otterbein at Perrysburg Perrysburg, OH23460Aug 18, 2025140
Green Hills Center West Liberty, OH32474Sep 11, 202561 · $16,801
Otterbein Gahanna Gahanna, OH23560May 13, 2026160
Otterbein Lebanon Retirement Community Lebanon, OH435154Sep 12, 202560
Otterbein Loveland Loveland, OH21360Aug 25, 2025160
Otterbein Middletown Franklin, OH34560Jan 8, 202690
Otterbein Monclova Monclova, OH23460Mar 27, 2025141 · $47,171
Otterbein New Albany New Albany, OH14260Feb 26, 2026111 · $23,980
Otterbein North Shore Lakeside, OH45520Mar 27, 202670
Otterbein Portage Valley Pemberville, OH33550Jun 18, 202580
Otterbein Springboro Centerville, OH34560Apr 30, 202690
Otterbein St Marys Retirement Community St Marys, OH44353Jun 25, 202660
Otterbein Sunset House Toledo, OH34424May 1, 202580
Otterbein Sunset Village Sylvania, OH23550Oct 24, 2024180
Otterbein Tipp City Tipp City, OH22599Apr 3, 2025140
Otterbein Union Township Batavia, OH33560Jan 15, 202671 · $7,008
Otterbein at Granville Granville, OH54522Apr 28, 202640
Otterbein at Maineville Maineville, OH34560Apr 3, 202584 · $59,449
Otterbein-Cridersville Cridersville, OH33550Apr 23, 2025100

Fines are those of the last three years, as the CMS Penalties file lists them; the file does not state whether a fine is under appeal.

Sources

Every fact in this article was read at the official sources below. Read November 21, 2026.

  1. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services: Provider Data Catalog: Provider Information (dataset 4pq5-n9py)
  2. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services: Provider Data Catalog: State US Averages (dataset xcdc-v8bm)
  3. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services: Provider Data Catalog: Ownership (dataset y2hd-n93e)
  4. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services: Provider Data Catalog: Penalties (dataset g6vv-u9sr)
  5. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services: Nursing Home Data Dictionary (updated October 2026)